≡Menu
Search

Arrest Record & Conviction Record Discrimination

Home
Employment Law
Workplace Discrimination
Arrest Record & Conviction Record Discrimination
family-law

Chicago Arrest Record & Conviction Record Discrimination Attorney

Were you denied employment, fired, demoted, or treated unfairly because of your arrest or conviction record? Illinois law provides important protections against unlawful employment discrimination based on arrest records and certain uses of conviction records.

At Pinkston Law Group, P.C., Attorney Danielle A. Pinkston represents employees and job applicants throughout Chicago and Illinois who have experienced unlawful arrest record or conviction record discrimination.

Schedule an employment law consultation to discuss your rights and legal options.

Call (773) 770-4771 or Schedule Your Consultation Online.

Chicago Arrest Record & Conviction Record Discrimination Attorney

Were You Denied a Job, Fired, or Treated Unfairly Because of Your Arrest or Criminal Conviction Record?

Your past should not automatically prevent you from building a successful career.

Perhaps you applied for a job, completed the interview process, and received a conditional offer—only to have the employer withdraw it after conducting a criminal background check.

Maybe your employer terminated you after discovering an old conviction that had no apparent connection to your job responsibilities.

You may have been denied a promotion because of a prior arrest that never resulted in a conviction.

Perhaps an employer told you that company policy prohibits hiring anyone with a criminal record.

Or maybe you received a notice that your background check disqualified you, without being given the explanation or opportunity to respond required by Illinois law.

Illinois law provides important employment protections concerning arrest records and conviction records.

However, the protections are not identical, and employers may lawfully consider certain conviction information in qualifying circumstances.

At Pinkston Law Group, P.C., Chicago employment attorney Danielle A. Pinkston represents Illinois employees experiencing workplace discrimination, unlawful employment practices, retaliation, and wrongful termination.

Our firm evaluates employment claims involving criminal background checks, arrest records, conviction records, hiring decisions, promotions, disciplinary actions, and termination.

If you believe an employer unlawfully relied on your criminal history, we can evaluate the circumstances and explain your legal options.

Schedule an Employment Law Consultation: Call 773-770-4771.

What Is Arrest Record and Conviction Record Discrimination?

Arrest record and conviction record discrimination involves employment decisions based on criminal history in circumstances prohibited by applicable law.

Illinois provides separate protections concerning arrest records and conviction records under the Illinois Human Rights Act.

These protections may affect decisions involving:

  • Hiring.
  • Job applications.
  • Conditional employment offers.
  • Criminal background checks.
  • Promotions.
  • Transfers.
  • Demotions.
  • Disciplinary actions.
  • Termination.
  • Other covered employment decisions.

For example, an employer may violate Illinois law by refusing to hire a qualified applicant solely because of a covered arrest that did not result in a conviction.

An employer may also violate Illinois conviction-record protections by rejecting an applicant because of a prior conviction without satisfying the applicable statutory requirements.

However, Illinois law does not prohibit every employment decision involving a criminal conviction.

Certain employers may consider conviction information when the law permits it, including when there is a substantial relationship between the conviction and the employment sought or held, or an unreasonable risk to property or the safety or welfare of specific individuals or the general public.

Learn more about workplace discrimination representation.

Is Arrest Record Discrimination Illegal in Illinois?

Illinois law prohibits qualifying employment discrimination based on arrest records.

The Illinois Human Rights Act protects against certain employment decisions based on an arrest, detention, or other covered criminal-history information that does not result in a conviction, subject to statutory definitions and exceptions.

For example, an employer may violate the law by refusing to promote an employee solely because the employee was previously arrested but never convicted.

The statute also addresses certain information concerning criminal charges or proceedings that did not result in a conviction.

However, Illinois law does not necessarily prevent an employer from considering independently obtained information about an employee’s actual conduct when otherwise lawful.

An arrest is not the same as proof that a person committed misconduct.

Review the Illinois Human Rights Act.

Is Conviction Record Discrimination Illegal in Illinois?

Yes, in qualifying circumstances.

Effective March 23, 2021, Illinois expanded the Illinois Human Rights Act to prohibit certain employment discrimination based on conviction records.

Under Section 2-103.1, an employer generally may not use a conviction record as the basis for an adverse employment decision unless:

  1. There is a substantial relationship between one or more previous criminal offenses and the employment sought or held; or
  2. Granting or continuing employment would involve an unreasonable risk to property or the safety or welfare of specific individuals or the general public.

The statute also establishes requirements for evaluating conviction information and providing notice before and after certain adverse employment decisions.

These protections do not automatically prohibit all background checks or all consideration of criminal convictions.

Review the Illinois Department of Human Rights and the Illinois Human Rights Act.

What Is the Difference Between an Arrest Record and a Conviction Record?

Understanding the difference is important because Illinois law provides different protections.

Arrest Record

An arrest record may concern an arrest, detention, or criminal proceeding that did not result in a conviction.

An arrest alone does not establish guilt.

Illinois law restricts qualifying employment discrimination based on covered arrest information.

Conviction Record

A conviction record concerns qualifying information indicating that an individual was convicted of a criminal offense.

Illinois law permits certain employment decisions involving conviction records when statutory requirements are satisfied.

Employers generally must conduct the required individualized assessment and follow applicable notice procedures before taking certain adverse actions based on conviction records.

What Is the Illinois Conviction Record Discrimination Law?

Illinois Human Rights Act Section 2-103.1 establishes important protections for applicants and employees with conviction records.

The statute generally requires employers to consider specific factors when determining whether a conviction has a substantial relationship to the position or presents an unreasonable risk.

Those factors include:

  • The length of time since the conviction.
  • The number of convictions.
  • The nature and severity of the conviction and its relationship to the safety and security of others.
  • The facts or circumstances surrounding the conviction.
  • The age of the individual at the time of the conviction.
  • Evidence of rehabilitation efforts.

The employer must consider the relevant statutory factors in making the required assessment.

A conviction does not automatically disqualify an applicant from every job.

However, the law permits certain adverse decisions when the statutory standards and procedures are satisfied.

What Is a Substantial Relationship Between a Conviction and a Job?

Illinois law recognizes a substantial relationship when consideration of the position and the conviction establishes the required connection between the criminal offense and the employment sought or held.

The statute includes consideration of whether the position offers an opportunity for the same or a similar offense to occur and whether the circumstances leading to the conduct may recur in the employment position.

For example, an employer may argue that a particular conviction has a substantial relationship to a position involving certain financial responsibilities.

However, the employer must satisfy the applicable statutory analysis.

A generalized assumption that anyone with a criminal record is untrustworthy is not the same as the individualized assessment required by Illinois law.

What Is an Unreasonable Risk Under Illinois Law?

An employer may be permitted to consider a conviction record when employing the individual would involve an unreasonable risk to property or the safety or welfare of specific individuals or the general public.

The assessment must be based on the applicable statutory factors and the circumstances of the position.

The existence of a conviction does not automatically establish an unreasonable risk.

The employer’s explanation and supporting evidence may be important in determining whether the decision complied with Illinois law.

Does Illinois Require Employers to Give Notice Before Rejecting an Applicant Because of a Conviction?

Yes, when the statutory conviction-record adverse-action procedures apply.

Before making a final adverse employment decision based on a conviction record, an employer generally must provide the individual with written preliminary notice.

The preliminary notice must include:

  • Identification of the disqualifying conviction or convictions.
  • The employer’s reasoning for the preliminary decision.
  • A copy of the conviction history report, if any.
  • An explanation of the individual’s right to respond.

The employer must provide at least five business days for the individual to respond before making a final decision.

The individual may provide evidence challenging the accuracy of the conviction information or evidence of rehabilitation or mitigating circumstances.

If the employer makes a final adverse decision, the statute generally requires written notice identifying the conviction or convictions, the reasoning, available internal challenge procedures, and the right to file a charge with the Illinois Department of Human Rights.

These statutory requirements are distinct from any additional notices required under federal background-check laws.

Examples of Arrest Record and Conviction Record Discrimination in Illinois

1. Denied Employment Because of an Arrest Without a Conviction

An employer may violate Illinois law by refusing to hire an applicant because of a covered arrest that did not result in a conviction.

For example, an applicant may be rejected after a background check reveals an old arrest even though the criminal charge was dismissed.

The employer’s actual reason and the statutory definition of arrest record matter.

Learn more about discriminatory hiring practices.

2. Rejected Because of an Old Conviction Unrelated to the Job

An employer may violate Illinois law by rejecting an applicant based on a conviction without satisfying the substantial-relationship or unreasonable-risk standards.

For example, an applicant may be rejected because of a decades-old conviction that has no demonstrated connection to the position.

The employer must evaluate the relevant statutory factors.

3. Denied a Promotion Because of a Criminal Record

Conviction-record protections may apply to promotion decisions.

For example, an employer may refuse to promote a qualified employee solely because of an old conviction without conducting the required analysis.

Learn more about failure to promote based on discrimination.

4. Fired After an Employer Discovers an Old Conviction

An employer may violate Illinois law by terminating an employee because of a conviction record without satisfying the statutory requirements.

For example, management may discover an old conviction during a background check and immediately fire the employee without the required assessment and notices.

However, certain positions may be subject to statutory restrictions or other legal requirements concerning criminal history.

Learn more about discriminatory termination.

5. Discriminatory Background Check Policies

An employer may violate applicable law by maintaining a blanket policy that automatically excludes applicants with conviction records without regard to the requirements of Illinois law.

For example, an employer may state that no applicant with any felony conviction will ever be hired.

The legality of the policy depends on the applicable law, position, and statutory exceptions.

6. Failure to Provide Required Conviction Record Notices

An employer may violate Illinois law by making a covered adverse employment decision based on conviction information without providing required preliminary or final notices.

For example, an employer may rescind a job offer without identifying the disqualifying conviction or allowing the applicant the required opportunity to respond.

7. Racial Discrimination Involving Criminal Background Checks

Criminal background check policies may also implicate Title VII when they involve intentional race discrimination or an unlawful disparate impact.

For example, an employer may apply criminal-history screening standards more harshly to Black applicants than to similarly situated white applicants.

Even a facially neutral policy may raise Title VII issues when it causes a legally cognizable disparate impact and is not justified under the applicable statutory standards.

Learn more about racial discrimination and review the EEOC’s criminal records guidance.

Can an Employer Ask About Your Criminal Record on a Job Application in Illinois?

Illinois has a Job Opportunities for Qualified Applicants Act, commonly associated with the state’s ban-the-box protections.

For covered employers and positions, the law generally restricts when an employer may inquire about or consider an applicant’s criminal history.

The law generally permits criminal-history inquiries after the applicant has been determined qualified and notified of selection for an interview, or, if there is no interview, after a conditional offer of employment.

Statutory exceptions apply.

The law does not prohibit every criminal background check or every criminal-history question.

The timing of the inquiry and the nature of the position matter.

What Is the Illinois Ban-the-Box Law?

The Illinois Job Opportunities for Qualified Applicants Act restricts certain early-stage criminal-history inquiries.

The purpose is to allow qualifying applicants to be evaluated based on qualifications before criminal history becomes part of the hiring process.

However, ban-the-box requirements and conviction-record discrimination protections are separate legal rules.

An employer may comply with the timing requirements of the ban-the-box law and still violate the Illinois Human Rights Act when making an unlawful decision based on a conviction record.

Conversely, a properly timed background check does not automatically make every resulting employment decision unlawful.

Can an Employer Withdraw a Job Offer After a Background Check?

Potentially, yes.

An employer may withdraw an offer when the decision is lawful under the applicable conviction-record standards, other employment laws, and any relevant statutory exceptions.

However, an employer may violate Illinois law by rescinding an offer because of a conviction record without satisfying the required analysis and procedures.

Federal law may also require separate disclosures, authorization, and adverse-action notices when an employer uses a third-party consumer reporting agency.

Review the Federal Trade Commission’s background-check guidance.

Can an Employer Consider an Expunged or Sealed Criminal Record?

Illinois law places important restrictions on the use and disclosure of certain expunged or sealed criminal records.

The applicable protections depend on the type of record, the position, and any statutory exceptions.

Some employers or licensing authorities may have special access to certain records.

Employees should not assume that all sealed or expunged records are treated identically in every employment setting.

Can You Sue if an Employer Uses an Incorrect Criminal Background Report?

Potentially.

If an employer relies on inaccurate criminal-history information, several laws may be relevant.

The Illinois Human Rights Act may apply when the decision involves conviction-record discrimination and required procedures.

The federal Fair Credit Reporting Act may also apply when a third-party consumer report is used and the employer fails to comply with applicable requirements.

For example, a background report may incorrectly attribute another person’s conviction to an applicant.

The applicant may have rights to dispute the information and challenge certain adverse-action procedures.

Review the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s information about background checks.

Can You Sue for Conviction Record Discrimination Without Being Fired?

Potentially, yes.

Illinois conviction-record protections may apply to covered employment decisions involving hiring, promotion, discipline, demotion, and other employment opportunities.

An employee does not necessarily have to be terminated before seeking legal advice.

For example, a qualified employee may have a claim if the employer unlawfully denies a promotion because of a conviction record.

How Do You Prove Arrest Record or Conviction Record Discrimination?

Relevant evidence may include:

  • Job applications.
  • Conditional employment offers.
  • Criminal background check reports.
  • Preliminary adverse-action notices.
  • Final adverse-action notices.
  • Emails and text messages.
  • Employer hiring policies.
  • Performance evaluations.
  • Promotion records.
  • Termination notices.
  • Evidence of rehabilitation.
  • Records concerning the accuracy of the criminal-history information.
  • Communications concerning the employer’s reasons for its decision.
  • A timeline of relevant events.

For conviction-record claims, evidence may concern whether the employer conducted the required statutory assessment and provided the required notices.

For Title VII claims, evidence may also concern racial disparities, inconsistent treatment, or unlawful disparate-impact practices.

Employees should preserve only records they are legally authorized to possess.

How Long Do You Have to File an Arrest Record or Conviction Record Discrimination Claim in Illinois?

Filing deadlines depend on the applicable law and the challenged conduct.

Illinois Human Rights Act Claims

For many alleged violations occurring on or after January 1, 2025, the general Illinois Department of Human Rights filing period is two years, subject to applicable statutory exceptions and procedural requirements.

Review the Illinois Department of Human Rights.

Federal Title VII Claims

In Illinois, employees generally must file an EEOC charge within 300 days of an actionable discriminatory employment decision.

A Title VII claim requires a qualifying theory of discrimination, such as race discrimination or an unlawful disparate-impact policy.

Criminal history alone is not an independently protected characteristic under Title VII.

Review the EEOC’s filing deadline guidance.

Other Claims

Claims involving the Fair Credit Reporting Act, the Job Opportunities for Qualified Applicants Act, or other statutes may involve different enforcement procedures and limitations periods.

Do not assume that filing a background-check dispute or an internal appeal automatically extends an employment discrimination deadline.

What Damages Can You Recover for Arrest Record or Conviction Record Discrimination?

Depending on the applicable law, evidence, and resulting harm, potential remedies may include:

  • Lost wages.
  • Back pay.
  • Lost employment benefits.
  • Reinstatement or other equitable relief.
  • Front pay when available.
  • Emotional distress damages under qualifying laws.
  • Attorney’s fees and litigation costs when authorized.
  • Other statutory relief.

The available remedies differ under the Illinois Human Rights Act, Title VII, the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and other laws.

Certain federal discrimination damages are subject to statutory caps.

Learn more about wrongful termination damages and compensation.

What Should You Do if You Believe an Employer Unlawfully Used Your Criminal Record?

If you suspect unlawful criminal-history discrimination, consider these steps:

  1. Preserve the job application and offer. Keep copies of the application, interview communications, and conditional offer.
  2. Request or preserve the background report. Review the information used by the employer.
  3. Review the accuracy of the record. Identify dismissed charges, incorrect information, or records that may be sealed or expunged.
  4. Preserve adverse-action notices. Keep preliminary and final notices from the employer.
  5. Document the employer’s explanation. Record the stated reason for the decision.
  6. Gather relevant rehabilitation evidence. When appropriate, preserve documents reflecting rehabilitation or mitigating circumstances.
  7. Track filing deadlines. Different statutes may have different procedures and limitations periods.
  8. Consider speaking with an employment attorney. Legal advice can help determine whether the employer complied with Illinois and federal law.

Frequently Asked Questions About Arrest Record and Conviction Record Discrimination

Is arrest record discrimination illegal in Illinois?

Yes. Illinois law prohibits qualifying employment discrimination based on covered arrest records, subject to statutory definitions and exceptions.

Can an employer refuse to hire me because of a felony conviction?

Potentially, but not automatically. Illinois law generally requires an applicable statutory basis and compliance with conviction-record procedures, subject to exceptions.

Can an employer ask about my criminal record during an interview?

Illinois ban-the-box rules restrict the timing of certain criminal-history inquiries. The answer depends on the employer, position, and applicable exceptions.

Can my employer fire me because of an old conviction?

An employer may be permitted to consider certain convictions, but it generally must satisfy applicable Illinois statutory standards and procedures.

Does an employer have to give me a chance to explain my conviction?

When Illinois conviction-record adverse-action procedures apply, the employer generally must provide preliminary written notice and at least five business days to respond.

Can an employer use an arrest that did not result in a conviction?

Illinois law restricts qualifying employment discrimination based on covered arrest information. The employer’s use of independently obtained conduct information may require a separate analysis.

Can I sue if my background check contains incorrect information?

Potentially. Depending on the circumstances, Illinois employment law and the Fair Credit Reporting Act may provide remedies.

Can criminal background check policies violate racial discrimination laws?

Yes. A criminal-history screening policy may violate Title VII when it involves intentional discrimination or unlawful disparate impact.

Speak With a Chicago Arrest Record & Conviction Record Discrimination Attorney

Were you denied employment, refused a promotion, disciplined, demoted, or terminated because of an arrest or criminal conviction record?

At Pinkston Law Group, P.C., Attorney Danielle A. Pinkston represents Illinois employees experiencing unlawful workplace discrimination and wrongful termination.

Our firm can evaluate the background-check process, employer explanations, statutory notices, criminal-history information, relevant evidence, and potential legal claims under federal and Illinois law.

Schedule an Employment Law Consultation

Pinkston Law Group, P.C.
Danielle A. Pinkston, Esq.
Chicago, Illinois

Call: 773-770-477

A Criminal Record Does Not Automatically Eliminate Your Employment Rights Under Illinois Law.

Advertising Material. Educational information only; not legal advice. Reading this page does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not predict future outcomes.

EXPERIENCED PERSONAL INJURY & FAMILY LAW ATTORNEY

Whether you’re dealing with a family law, civil rights violation, or a personal injury case, you and your family’s best interests are our top priority. Attorney Danielle A. Pinkston of Pinkston Law Group utilizes her extensive legal knowledge to resolve your case, no matter how complex it may be. We share your goals and work closely with you, delivering the exceptional services you need.

  • Innovative solutions to your most pressing challenges.
  • Individualized legal advice you can depend on.
  • Skilled representation in a wide range of practice areas.
Check Out More

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

Personal Injury

Injury lawyer who is ready to help those who have suffered as a result of an auto crash or other personal injury.

Matrimony and Family Law

Family Law

A skilled matrimonial and family law attorney ready to vigorously advocate for you.

Matrimony and Family Law

Civil Rights

Civil Rights

Aggressive and dedicated civil rights attorney helping individuals get the justice they deserve.